Imagine two clients who have each paid off a credit card.

One says, “It took some difficult choices, but I have shown myself that I can do this.”

The other says, “I was lucky. Give it a few months and I will probably be back where I started.”

The same milestone. Two very different conclusions about what comes next.

As financial advisers and coaches, we might celebrate both achievements and move on to the next goal. But there is something here worth staying with.

What has each client learnt about their own capability?

This question has been shaping my thinking about financial self-efficacy and its place in Purpose Driven Financial Coaching. Beyond asking whether clients believe they can manage their money, I am interested in how they arrive at that belief and how it changes through experience.

Self-efficacy concerns our belief in our ability to carry out a particular action. In a financial conversation, it might sound like, “I believe I can review my spending each week,” or, “I can have this difficult money conversation with my partner.”

It is more specific than feeling good about ourselves. A person may feel capable of running a business and still feel unable to open their personal bank statement.

But where does that assessment of capability come from?

The meaning between experience and belief

Albert Bandura identified four main sources of self efficacy: our own achievements, observing others, persuasion from others, and physiological states. Crucially, he also recognised that the effect of these experiences depends on how we interpret them. Success does not automatically produce a stronger belief in capability. [1]

So the invitation here builds on an existing part of his theory.

What if we listened more closely to how clients decide what their experiences say about them?

A client may successfully follow a spending plan and conclude, “I am learning to make choices.” Another may conclude, “I only managed because you were checking on me.”

Both interpretations deserve exploration. Perhaps the second client needed considerable support. We need to understand what they did independently, what the support made possible, and what they could realistically repeat.

The purpose is to help them make a fair assessment of their capability, grounded in evidence.

From what happened to who I am

Listen to the difference between these statements:

“I have not saved during the past six months.”

“I cannot save.”

“I am hopeless with money.”

The first describes a period of financial behaviour. The second predicts capability. The third makes a judgement about identity.

Somewhere along the way, an experience has become a conclusion about the person.

An ontological coaching perspective invites us to explore how clients make sense of themselves and their financial lives. We pay attention to their language, the moods and emotions they experience, and how they notice and respond through their bodies. Together with their history and assumptions, these offer a way to explore what feels possible to them and why. We can refer to these familiar ways of making sense of experience as a person’s Structure of Interpretation.

This is the connection I am exploring between self-efficacy and ontological coaching: how our way of interpreting financial experiences shapes our assessment of what we can do, and how taking action can, in turn, reshape that interpretation. This integration is a conceptual proposition rather than an empirically validated model of financial self-efficacy.

It gives us another question to bring to the conversation:

“When you say you cannot save, what experiences are you drawing on, and what have you concluded from them?”

We might discover a skill that needs developing, an unrealistic plan, or a family message that has gone unquestioned for years.

We might also discover that there simply is no money left to save.

Sometimes the next step teaches us something new

There is a temptation, when exploring meaning and identity, to assume that deeper understanding must come before action.

Yet sometimes doing something differently helps us see ourselves differently.

Consider a client who says, “I cannot face my finances.”

The next useful step may be to open one statement together. Notice the discomfort. Understand three transactions. Make one decision.

Then pause.

“What did you do today that you thought you could not do?”

“What helped, and what would you need to do this again?”

The action creates evidence. The reflection helps the client consider what that evidence means.

Their assessment might shift from “I cannot face my finances” to “I can look at one part at a time, with support.”

That is a modest, credible change. It creates somewhere to begin.

Supporting doing and exploring being

This gives us two useful dimensions of coaching.

First order learning helps clients improve what they do. We might clarify a spending plan, practise a conversation, automate a payment or develop a skill.

Second order learning invites clients to observe the interpretations from which they act. What does spending represent? What makes asking for help uncomfortable? What happens when a setback becomes proof that they will never change?

For example, a client may experience spending as a way of belonging. A spending limit may help, while a conversation about belonging may reveal why that limit is difficult to maintain.

Understanding this meaning gives us something to work with. The client can consider other ways to honour the need while taking responsibility for the financial consequences.

Neither dimension has to come first. A useful action can open a deeper conversation. A new understanding can make a practical action possible.

Notice the whole person, and the real circumstances

A client might say they are ready to call a creditor while noticing a tight chest and shallow breathing.

We can ask, “What do you notice as you imagine making that call?” We can explore their experience without deciding for them what the sensation means.

Similarly, when a client says, “Nothing will help,” we can gently explore what feels closed to them and whether one manageable possibility remains.

But we must also examine the circumstances. Irregular income, unemployment, illness and family responsibilities can constrain financial action. Confidence cannot create a surplus where essential expenses exceed income.

Sometimes our most useful contribution is practical problem solving, appropriate advice or access to further support.

Start where the client’s ability to act is constrained.

What will this experience come to mean?

At the next review, alongside checking what a client has done, we could ask:

“What does this experience tell you about what you can do?”

“Which part was your contribution, and which conditions helped?”

“What could you carry into the next step?”

And when something has gone wrong:

“What needs to change in the plan, and what are you concluding about yourself?”

For me, this is an important possibility in financial coaching. We help clients take meaningful action, and we help them examine what they learn about themselves through that action.

Financial prosperity includes developing the capacity to participate in our financial lives with greater clarity and responsibility, in service of what matters to us.

When your clients leave a conversation, what have they learnt about their money, and what have they learnt about themselves?

Reference and evidence note

[1] Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191